Manhattan Life Medicare Supplement Review
One of the oldest insurance companies in America, Manhattan Life offers solid Medicare supplement coverage with competitive rates.
Compare Manhattan Life Rates →Pros
- 174-year track record
- Competitive rates
- Strong in Texas/South
- Good plan selection
Cons
- Lower name recognition in North
- Online tools less robust
Best For
Seniors who want a carrier with an exceptionally long track record at a competitive price point.
Manhattan Life Rates by State
Manhattan Life monthly rates — age 65, female
Carrier | Monthly Rate | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Arizona | $136/mo | AZ |
| Colorado | $136/mo | CO |
| Florida | $136/mo | FL |
| Georgia | $136/mo | GA |
| Iowa | $136/mo | IA |
| Kansas | $136/mo | KS |
| Kentucky | $136/mo | KY |
| Missouri | $136/mo | MO |
| Nebraska | $136/mo | NE |
| North Carolina | $136/mo | NC |
| Ohio | $136/mo | OH |
| South Carolina | $136/mo | SC |
| South Dakota | $136/mo | SD |
| Tennessee | $136/mo | TN |
| Texas | $136/mo | TX |
Quick Savings Estimator
Enter your current monthly premium to see your potential savings.
Our Verdict
Manhattan Life is a well-rated carrier with a strong track record. Seniors who want a carrier with an exceptionally long track record at a competitive price point. That said, Medicare supplement coverage is identical across all carriers — so the most important factor is price. We always recommend comparing Manhattan Life's rates against alternatives in your state before enrolling or renewing.
Compare Alternatives
Mutual of Omaha (AM Best: A+) averages $148/month for Plan G — comparable to Manhattan Life.
Medico (AM Best: A) averages $132/month for Plan G — about $4/month less than Manhattan Life.
Aetna (AM Best: A) averages $151/month for Plan G — comparable to Manhattan Life.
Is Manhattan Life Your Best Option?
Our agents compare all carriers side-by-side — including rates ${carrier.name} won't tell you about.
- Same exact coverage, lower price
- Takes less than 5 minutes
- No obligation, no spam
Free service · Licensed agents · No obligation